This was a really
interesting reading for me, that was dense so I had many thoughts (and some
areas of confusion; so I will break it down.
- The distinction between Soma and Body
Where the author describes how the body is perceived from within the first-person perception, it reminds me of a few things I learned growing up. I used to always think about how I have no idea what I truly look like. I only see myself through a mirror, or a camera, or photos. It reminds me of the time I read that humans think they are 5 times more attractive than they actually are. I remember thinking how ugly am I then? The last thing I pieced together was a campaign that Dove made, where they asked people to describe themselves to a sketch artist, then have others describe them, and the side-by-side results were shocking. I encourage you to read it: link.
The Third-person viewpoint was also interesting to me because it was stressed how third-person views are used for psychology and medicine. This is relevant to some recent conversations I had where we criticized the eligibility of most medicine and psychology because of their inherent biases. Things like Autism, ADHD, heart attacks, and many more topics in medicine and psychology were studied on men. Where women don’t have the same symptoms, they are very often misdiagnosed and suffer their lives. This issue is more prevalent in Women of colour (such as how in the UK, women of colour are 5 times more likely to die of childbirth). The author touches upon this slightly, when he says ‘to ignore essential data, either willfully or innocently.’
- The soma is self-regulating and self-sensing
“When we play the role of scientist and observe a rock, nothing changed for the rock. But the soma that is being observed is not only aware of itself through self-observation, but it is also simultaneously in the process of modifying itself before the observer’s eyes. ” Somas are not bodies, and self-awareness is only the first several distinctions of the human soma. Humans are said to be self-aware, and engaged in it, constantly reacting to their first-person point of view, as well as reacting to how they are perceived in third person point of view. Forgive me if I’m taking this in a different context, but I can’t help but thinking of identity politics when I consider this. I took a course in Identity politics, and so I consider ‘self-regulating and self-sensing’ to be very interesting interconnected with ideas like Confirmation Bias, situating self in relation to who others are around you, and herd mentality.
- Consciousness and Awareness
“Human consciousness is, in fine, the instrument of human freedom.” The author describes consciousness are a learned function, an instrument to human freedom, and awareness as mostly negative, but focused. But what happens when they go hand in hand for a long period of time? For example, being a woman, I was taught to always be aware of strangers, more specifically men around me. Over years and years of practicing this awareness, it became involuntary. It is involuntary when I walk into a space, scan the room, count the people, check the exits. I don’t do it consciously anymore, but if you ask me at a random moment how many men are in the room, I will know. I can sense when someone is looking at me even if they are out of my peripheral vision. I know when someone is following me, and I know when someone is just walking behind me. Are these all involuntary somatic events, or were they development of being conscious and aware, that lead to it becoming involuntary?
- Somatic learning and Sensory-motor Amnesia
Here is where I get
confused. I know conditioning neither requires focusing of awareness nor does
it result in the learning of conscious somatic actions and that it attempts to
reduce the repertoire of voluntary consciousness, so is that what my reaction
to stranger danger has become? Was this self-conditioning? My second question
is, how voluntary is conditioning? Yes,
technically, I chose to be aware and (borderline) paranoid of strangers, but
was this so much as my choice as it was an environmental development?
When it comes to sensory-motor amnesia, I don’t understand it at all: would love it if someone could give me an example to help them think through it!